When it hits close to home

My dad sends me conspiracy videos every day. How do I talk to him?

You used to call your dad on Sundays just to hear how his week went. Now another video lands on your phone, and you’re already bracing for the conversation you used to look forward to.

Meet Nora

An illustrative story

Nora used to call her dad on Sundays. He’d tell her what he’d cooked and ask how her car was running. Now she often gets a link before breakfast and another before lunch.

Last Sunday she picked up ready to explain why a clip was misleading. He heard her out for about thirty seconds, then asked if she thought he was stupid. By the time they hung up, neither of them knew how the other was doing.

She misses her dad. She also dreads answering the phone, and he can tell she’s calling less.

The argument has become a test of the relationship

When Nora checks a claim, she thinks she’s doing what she’d want someone to do for her. Her dad hears it as a question about whether she still respects his judgment. And when he sends another clip, she starts to wonder whether he wants to talk to her or just wants her to agree.

Once every link carries that much, even a small correction can take up the entire call. They’re both trying to be heard, and both end up with one more reason to call less often.

What would you like your next call to be about?

Nora can ask what worried him about one clip. If the discussion takes over again, she can say, “I’ve got ten more minutes and I’d like to hear how your week went.” He may still want to keep talking about the video. She can decide when to end the call and call again another Sunday.

Further reading from the University of Washington’s Center for an Informed Public

What the book helps you change

What could be different?

Sven Masterson’s book begins with an extraordinary claim that people interpret in opposite ways. It helps you stay curious about why a story lands so differently for someone you love, think through the claim for yourself, and keep a conversation open without agreeing to spend every call on it.

  • FromOpening with everything the video got wrong

    ToAsking what caught your dad’s attention

  • FromFeeling as if warmth would mean agreement

    ToTelling him you love him and where you see things differently

  • FromGiving every link the rest of your evening

    ToChoosing one thing you’ll discuss and when you’re done

  • FromAvoiding the Sunday call altogether

    ToCalling to ask how he’s doing and making time for the answer

A couple of questions about the book

What does a book about aliens have to do with the videos my dad keeps sending me?

In the alien story, two people can hear the same thing and come away trusting completely different people. That can happen in a family too. The book helps you understand why a claim can feel personal and how to stay curious about your dad while keeping your own judgment.

Do I have to talk through every video to stay close to him?

You can care about what’s worrying him and still want some of the call for the rest of his life. The book helps you think about how to say that in a way that sounds like you.

Make room for a Sunday call again

The book helps you understand what makes a story feel personal and what happens when a disagreement starts to feel like a threat to belonging. That gives you a way to take the claim on its merits, speak plainly, and decide how much of the relationship you want to spend discussing it.

If you miss hearing about your dad’s week, read it with your next call in mind. You can be honest about what you think and make time for the person you called.